Summary
Dexter: Original Sinhas become a massive hit on Paramount+ with Showtime, but with four episodes to go, there is one key character who has yet to make an appearance, and it’s baffling to longtime fans.Tom Matthews was a recurring character in the original series, and he had significant links to Harry Morgan, but he is nowhere to be seen in the prequel series.
Dexter andDebra Morganwould always seek answers from Matthews when it came to their late father, and it was clear he was a known figure to them as they grew up, so where is he?Aaron Spencer and Bobby Watt have been seen as Harry’s close confidantes inOriginal Sin, but the series needs to introduce Matthews sooner rather than later.
Dexter: Original Sin
Starring
Patrick Gibson, Christian Slater, Molly Brown, James Martinez, Christina Milian, Alex Shimizu, Reno Wilson, Patrick Dempsey, Joe Pantoliano, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Matthew William and the voice of Michael C. Hall
Created by
Directed By
Michael Lehmann
At the start ofthe originalDexterseries, Tom Matthew was the Captain at Miami Metro, and he was close toDexter and Debra Morgandue to a personal and professional relationship with their father, Harry Morgan prior to his death.Original Sintakes place over the course of two weeks, and it is around one year before Harry dies, meaning Matthews should have already been introduced.Matthews was the one who told Dexter that his adoptive father actually committed suicide, instead of overdosing on his heart medication. Harry supposedly entrusted Matthews with the job of looking out for Dexter and Debra, and he did just that throughout the original series.
There is a fan theory that suggestsMatthews knew about Dexter’s dark passenger, especially as he appears to shut down Maria LaGuerta’s suggestions that the forensic analyst is actually the Bay Harbor Butcher in the penultimate season of the original show.Ascasting announcements for Dexter’s prequelcame to light, fans were puzzled that nobody had been cast in the role of Tom Matthews.However, an actor calledMatthew William was cast in a recurring roleas a ‘Miami Metro Police Officer’ inOriginal Sinback in September 2024, and he does have a striking likeness to a young Geoff Pierson, who played Matthews in the original series. Having said that, Matthews still hasn’t turned up, and its unclear if this particular actor will be playing him.
Original Sin Has To Introduce Matthews At Some Point And There Is Probably A Logical Reason Why He hasn’t Turned Up Yet
Patrick Dempsey plays Aaron Spencer inOriginal Sin, a role that Matthews would later take on.It’s quite possible that Matthews will take over from Spencer at the end of the first series, and become close to Harry Morgan in the lead up to his death.Spencer is one of Harry’s closest friends in the prequel series, alongside Bobby Watt, and they both appear to be filling the void left by Matthews in the prequel. However, fans shouldn’t be too concerned, as there is still plenty of time for Matthews to turn up.Dempsey is only contracted to one season ofOriginal Sin, so there is every chance his character will either be killed off or depart Miami Metro by the end of the debut season, especially with the current storyline putting his young son in danger.
There is another possibility: Maybe Matthews wasn’t as close to Harry Morgan as he claimed to be, and he was lying to Dexter and Debra all along.Matthews was always a shady character with political ambitions, so what if Harry uncovered one of his secrets and Matthews had him killed?It was quite strange that Matthews initially lied to Dexter and Debra about how their father died, before admitting he actually committed suicide. Would Harry Morgan really kill himself? Christian Slater’s iteration of the character inOriginal Sinhas peeled back the layers of what he was really like, and it raises doubts over Matthews' version of events. Harry was supposedly so horrified by what Dexter had become, that he took his own life. Let’s not forget, it was Harry who trained his son to become aserial killer with a code, so seeing him actually carrying out a murder wouldn’t necessarily tip him over the edge. There is something more to it, and ifOriginal Sinis renewed for a second season, fans might finally get the real answer, if Matthews eventually turns up.
